Can utopia exist when if someone wishes to change that utopias peace? Augustine writes “In fact, even when men wish a present state of peace to be disturbed they do so not because they hate peace, but because they desire the present peace to be exchanged for one that suits their wishes” (866). So what if someone living in a utopia wished to change the present peace? The example that comes to mind is Omelas and the people who leave because they disagree with the treatment of the child. What if rather than simply leaving, they wished to change the current state of peace? War and utopia don't seem to coincide with each other. If two utopias were at war, the result would be each becoming a dystopia. To avoid dystopian consequences, I became curious of whether there was a “right peace” and a “wrong peace” and if The City of God held the answer.
What is St. Augustine’s definition of Godly righteous peace?
The answer, as far as I could discern, is that there is “earthly peace” and “eternal peace.” Earthly peace is when man “observes” two things: “to do no harm to anyone, and, secondly, to help everyone whenever possible” (873). Augustine’s idea of peace opposes Plato’s definition of justice because he concludes that justice is not “meddling” in other people's lives. Augustine also states that earthly peace is to be on a pilgrimage towards eternal blessings and peace. One question I had is as follows: is there no such thing as “true” earthly peace, but rather one must accept that a real sense of peace will only come when a person enters the Heavenly City?
That is an interesting point that you bring up: that people have different ideas of what peace is. I think that is the main reason utopia is such an unattainable concept. There are so many differing views that it's impossible to please everyone. I guess utopia would only really be possible with multiple small utopias that are geared towards specific desires
ReplyDeleteMy mind immediately went to Plato's definition of peace as I was reading this. There truly seems to be a stark contrast between his idea of peace and St. Augustine's 'earthly' peace. I agree with your thoughts that perhaps there can be no true peace on earth. I interpret the idea of earthly peace as more of an inner peace that lays the foundation for cooperation with your fellow man. Heavenly peace is an abstract concept that my mortal brain has a hard time grasping, however!
ReplyDelete